Friday, October 24, 2014

My Nomination for the Next CGGC Executive Director

No one.

The CGGC is at a point where it has to either, well to put it indelicately, poop or get off the pot as far as the authority of the Bible is concerned.

Our current leadership spent five years writing and promoting a new We Believe defining the Bible as the only rule in the CGGC. The Ad Council gave it its authority.

Now, in the wake of Ed Rosenberry's resignation, the same leadership has launched a search for a new Executive Director--a position for which there is no support in the Word. They continue to define the holder of that position as the "Chief Executive Officer" of the denomination.

Show me a CEO under the "rule" of the Word.

If we hire another CEO, the people of the CGGC will have to choose an authority: the Word or the CEO.

I, for one, will never even consider submitting to the authority of another denominational CEO.

Trash this search.

Open the Word.

Start over.

Thursday, October 23, 2014

Every day with, uh, bill...

Friends,

I've got a lot going on in my life these days and I don't have as much time as I'd like to do the sort of blogging I've done on this blog in the past in which I write lengthy comments, going through many drafts, often, over a period of weeks or months.  I do continue to work on those threads.

However, lately I've been thinking of adopting the method of my friend Dan Horwedel in his excellent blog, "Every day with dan..." and to make more personal observations often shorter in length and without any thought or care that they might provoke dialog and, certainly, without the intention to respond myself.

So, somewhat in that vein...

-------------------------------

It is our intention at Faith to discontinue the practice of taking an offering.  We hope to do that soon.  My goal personally is that we will do it beginning on January 1, 2015. 

We still have an obligation to our current landlord--to fulfill the financial obligation of our lease.  I hope we can pay it off early.  We do have one or two other small obligations that we will need to meet.  Then, as far as I am concerned, we will no longer funnel money through the church.

I think I can say that we all believe that Jesus taught, or at least endorsed, tithing. (Mt. 23:23)  As for me and my house, we will continue to give.  We simply no longer believe in tithing to a local church.  We see no biblical basis for such a practice.

So, as soon as we can, we will be setting our Church Treasurer free.

Reflections on the MLI Reunion

If you read the eNewses of September 26 and October 3, you know that past participants in the Missional Leadership Initiative were invited to come together about a month ago, as Ed says it, "to return for a kind of reunion with an agenda."

I don't have many reflections worth mentioning, but I believe some of my insights have value--especially as our body considers how it will move on from the Rosenberry era.

I can detail two realities that I, very personally, think are worth mentioning:

1.  I wasn't invited.

I didn't even know there was a reunion planned until I read Ed's brief mention of it in his article on the recent GC Ad Council meeting.  The following week's eNews was Ed's account of the MLI gathering of Eagles--as a fait accompli. 

I was stunned to realize that it had been planned and held and that I had not gotten even a sniff of it from my brethren and sisters in Findlay.

I wrote a note to a friend whose heart has some passions for the Lord and the world that are similar to mine, who has also completed MLI, asking if, like me, he also wasn't invited.  To my surprise, he told me that he had been invited.  At that point I began to wonder how small the universe of the excluded is.

In his reply, noting that I was not invited, my friend asked, "What's up with that?"

While I have my thoughts, I think that his is a good question.

Before MLI was even a twinkle in GC Leadership's eyes, I was calling for missionality in the CGGC and I was living it and participating in it in my local setting.  Since my two years in MLI ended, I have continued to support the goals of MLI and still, today, live out missionality with a passion that is at least as great as anyone in the CGGC.

So indeed, "What's up with that?"

What could have possessed the people making the decision to exclude me from having the opportunity to share my missional joys and sorrows, my triumphs and failures, in community with my brothers and sisters on mission in the CGGC?

I do have a theory.  But, I do not know.

2.  In spite of my absence, my presence was felt.

A telling passage in Ed's glowing account of the successes of the CGGC missional and of the denomination in general is this:
"Friends, God is alive and moving across the CGGC. Heed not the naysayers."
 Obviously, Ed could not forget that there are those inside the CGGC who reside beyond the borders of his preferred world in which we all just get along and in which the CGGC word is spoken and received in unity and with power.

But, "naysayer-s?"--in the plural?  Who, besides me could Ed mean?  Who, besides me, in the CGGC is actually saying nay?

Certainly, Ed's innovations have been opposed by minorities--sometimes fairly large minorities--but actually speaking nay?  To me, it feels very much as if I am a lone voice crying in the CGGC wilderness.  I know that some agree at least on points that I make.  They tell me so.  But, no one I know of is voicing--i.e., saying--nay.

Now, please understand, while I may be saying nay, I'm not saying what Ed says I'm saying.  I'm not denying, as he says, "God is alive and moving across the CGGC."  To this moment, I neither confirm nor deny that He is.  I've never really talked about that at all and I rarely have thought in those terms.

I can say that what I see around me is churches that are either--with very, very few exceptions--struggling to hold their own or are declining and some of them are declining rapidly.  I acknowledge that there are some exceptional stories of churches doing well--but not nearly enough of them to justify Ed's glorious accounts of growth across our body.

But, I will say now that, according to the standards established by the Bible which is, our "only" "rule," that God is NOT alive and moving across the CGGC.  Certainly, the institution of the CGGC is in better shape than it was when Ed's regime began. 

But, when I read the Word--in both Testaments--I see, as fruit of God's blessing, two things taking place among God's people:

First, they repent.
Second, the turn from their evil ways.

While Ed often reports of his travels to the churches and Regions across the CGGC, I can't recall a single account either of repentance or of conversion under his leadership.

By the standard of the Word, since Ed has raised the issue, I don't think God is alive and moving across the CGGC. 

Clearly, the institution has been undergirded.  But, as far as I can tell, God's work is still not being accomplished.  Hearts are not being moved.  Lives are not changing.

-----------------

So, these are my reflections--in absentia--on the MLI Reunion.  Sorry I missed it.  I, and the people with whom I serve here at Faith, no doubt, could have benefited from an invitation.

But, alas...

Monday, October 6, 2014

Organized Hypocrisy in Action

My thirteenth Characteristic of the CGGC Brand is Organized Hypocrisy:
13.  Organized Hypocrisy.  There is illogic and outright contradiction among the things the CGGC claims to be true about itself.  This illogic and contradiction is, in reality, deeply rooted, highly intentional and carefully executed.  A hypocrite is an actor: "...a person who acts in contradiction to his or her stated beliefs or feelings."  It is a positive and essential value of the CGGC to speak one message and to, without qualm, act out another that is entirely disconnected from that avowed principle.
This characteristic of who the CGGC is and what it does is depicted vividly in leadership's search for the new Executive Director, or as the job description has it, the new CEO.

Note the Job Description for the position which defines the ED as the CGGC's CEO and describes that person as its overseer of personnel and its programs.

This description is a copy and paste from the innocent days when our leaders created the position as part of a series of changes they attempted which featured the 35,000 by 2000 program--which, of course, failed miserably, so miserably that recently Ed Rosenberry was celebrating 28,000 in worship in 2013.

My question is:  What in the WORD is a denominational ED who is a CEO overseeing personnel and programs?!?

The hypocrisy is particularly stark and outrageous because the same leadership team worked tenaciously for five years to gain the adoption of a new We Believe which states, "We believe the Bible is the inspired, infallible authority, the Word of God, our only rule for following Jesus in every aspect of our life" and then added a 2013 Statement of Faith which affirms, "We believe that the Bible is the divinely inspired Word of God, the only infallible rule of faith and practice."

These two statements created afresh two authorities over all of the people of the CGGC:

1.  The Bible as our, well, ruler, that which rules us, and,
2.  The two declarations of the CGGC Eldership both of which denote that the highest authority in our body is the Bible.

All of the people in the CGGC--especially those who reside on the mountaintop--must, therefore, be ruled by the Bible.  They must based on the authority of the CGGC community represented by the General Conference in session.

So, the first question is:  What in the WORD is a denominational ED who is a CEO overseeing personnel and programs?

The answer, I think we can all agree, is nowhere.

If you find such a person in the Word, please show us from the Word.

A second question becomes:  Where do the powers that be get off defying the Word and the
Eldership by creating the search for a denominational CEO who oversees, uh, personnel and programs?  Where in the Word do you find church personnel and programs?

This is quintessential and highly organized hypocrisy!
There is illogic and outright contradiction among the things the CGGC claims to be true about itself.  This illogic and contradiction is, in reality, deeply rooted, highly intentional and carefully executed.  A hypocrite is an actor: "...a person who acts in contradiction to his or her stated beliefs or feelings."  It is a positive and essential value of the CGGC to speak one message and to, without qualm, act out another that is entirely disconnected from that avowed principle.
A third question:

Why shouldn't all of the mountaintoppers who are a part of creating the search for a new CGGC CEO not be tried by the Eldership for insubordination?

I can see no reason.

Thursday, October 2, 2014

CGGC Executive Director Job Description--Makes MY Skin Crawl! How About Your's?


I pasted this straight from CGGC.org.  It didn't paste perfectly, though the text is all there.

If you don't recognize it, it comes, with only the slightest tweaking, from the wisdom of the same group of people who came up with 35,000 by 2000:  The same people who defined "More and Better Disciples" as an increase in average attendance in worship services.

Can you say, "Institutionalism?"  Can you say, "Hierarchy?"  Can you shout, "TRADITION!?"

I don't know if you can.  But, the Ad Council and the Search Committee certainly can.

Can you say, "Repentance" or "Change?"  Can you act under the "rule" of God's Word?

Clearly, they can't.

This has to be stopped before it's too late!

-----------------------------------------

Note:  Bold Italics are my emphasis


GENERAL CONFERENCE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR



A. Position Description
The General Conference Executive Director is the chief executive officer of the Churches of God, General Conference. His primary role is that of vision caster and overseer of the personnel in Findlay and programs that serve the local churches in the conferences of the Churches of God, General Conference.
B. Organizational Responsibilities

1. Responsible to: Administrative Council of General Conference
2. Responsible for: Spiritual and managerial oversight of Directors, staff and programs of the Churches of God as directed by the Administrative Council
3. Related closely with: Administrative Council Members, General Conference staff and Directors, Conference Leaders, Winebrenner Theological Seminary, church leadership and other denominational leaders in the larger Body of Christ

C. Position Qualifications
The following qualifications shall, to the degree possible, be regarded as minimum requirements, excepting where the person by reason of experience or related skills, has demonstrated abilities.
1. Experience

a. Have at least 10 years experience as an effective servant-leader with sufficient evidences of team success
 
b. Have had leadership responsibilities in the management and administration of the larger work of the church, (e.g. Conference/Region or General Conference level)
c. Have had sufficient involvement in ecumenical endeavors and relations to relate to interdenominational activities
d. Have had adequate exposure to the total ministries of the church to provide a broad experience compatible with the inner workings of the Churches of God
e. Have demonstrated skills in personnel management, corporate planning and finance, along with experience in problem solving and crisis management
2. Education a. Wherever possible, hold a degree from a recognized theological seminary. However, training in theological studies, management, business/personnel administration coupled with demonstrated performance in these areas may serve to satisfy this requirement.
b. Possess biblical knowledge supportive of an adequate perception and understanding of the church should be viewed as an essential part of the educational foundation of the person.
c. Hold a personal theological position that is biblical and compatible with the We Believe statement of the CGGC.



3. Personal

a. Evidence personal integrity, good moral character, Christian commitment, and financial responsibility (1 Timothy, Titus)
b. Evidence an understanding of the fear of the Lord and knowledge of God (Proverbs 2:5) in deliberations and decisions
c. Be a person given to neatness and good taste in matters of dress and appearance and have reasonably sound health
d. Manage own household well and be willing to do extensive travel, given the broad scope of the church and its various ministries
e. Demonstrate a loyalty to the Churches of God and her traditional doctrinal position, possessing the respect and cooperative support of the church

D. Job Summary
1. The Executive Director - General Objectives a. Develop a team to minister effectively to the Churches of God in the following areas:
1) Church Planting

2) Cross-Cultural Ministries

3) Finance

4) Denominational Communications

5) Transformational Ministries

6) Publications

7) Stewardship and Capital Development

8) Personnel

9) Administration

b. Develop working relationships with the Conference/Regional Leaders (appointed and elected) of the Churches of God, General Conference
c. Coordinate vision casting and program development with Winebrenner Theological Seminary
2. Managerial Roles
a. Planning
(1) In consultation with the Administrative Council and conference/regional leaders, develop a strategic vision for the Churches of God, General Conference.
(2)Develop short-range and long-range plans for denominational growth, development, and renewal for ascertaining needs, setting objectives, developing strategies, proposing programs and budgets, evaluating results, networking regions and churches, and identifying external resources.
(3) Design effective systems for recruiting, training, and deploying General Conference personnel on the basis of spiritual giftedness and expertise.
b. Organizing
(1)Oversee the development of an effective organization by nurturing a relational chain of concern and span of care.
(2)Work with the General Conference Team to develop position descriptions and oversee the selection of personnel to accomplish effective ministry.
(3)Oversee and facilitate the development and implementation of action plans for General Conference ministries.
(4)Conduct regular Directors and staff meetings to insure coordinated, resourced planned activities.
c. Leading
(1)Clearly communicate the denominational strategy to all denominational membership and leadership.
(2)Recognize, recruit, test, train, empower, and deploy persons to minister, based on character, faithfulness, gifts, education, experience, and availability.
(3)Be available as advisor and resource person to the Administrative Council, conference/regional leaders and WTS staff.
(4)Handle personnel problems at the General Conference office which have not been settled through regular procedures.
(5)Network resources to provide opportunities for growth to all churches.
d. Controlling
(1)Meet regularly with the Executive Committee of the Administrative Council to evaluate progress and problems related to the denomination.
(2)Meet regularly with Directors of Ministry and staff to review progress and expedite team proposals for needed change.
(3)Monitor and evaluate new changing paradigms in cross-cultural ministries.
(4)Provide evaluation of all Ministry Directors and staff.
E. Recurring Priorities
1. Regular involvement in seminars and events to continue to gain knowledge, skills, and experience.
2. Assist General Conference team to recruit and train competent people to be part of the Churches of God ministries.
3. Motivate General Conference staff to quality relationships and a lifestyle of Christian discipleship.
4. Facilitate the redefining and refining of objectives, programs, and job descriptions for Directors and staff ministries.
F. Specific Areas of Oversight
1. Staff
a. Oversee the enhancement of skills through training
b. Guide in strategic planning of programs
c. Make sure a variety of opportunities are available for spiritual growth and enrichment

2. Possible Programs

a. Regional and Conference Visits

b. Special Programs

G. Scheduling

1. Reports

a. Specific reports requested by Administrative Council

b. Triennial report to General Conference

2. Meetings

a. Regularly scheduled staff meetings

b. Scheduled Conference Leadership meetings

c. Administrative Council and other meetings and services as needed
d. Conferences for personal edification
e. Serve on Winebrenner Theological Seminary Board
 

Monday, September 29, 2014

DESIRED ATTRIBUTES FOR THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR

Gang,
 
I pulled this off of CGGC.org this morning.  As Sir Arthur Conan Doyle would say, "The game is afoot."
 
Read it over.  I'd appreciate comments here or off the blog.
 
Two, I believe, crucial theological questions to bring to the denomination's "next chapter:"
 
1.  What APEST gifting(s) do the powers that be have in mind?
 
2.  Who, among the great men and women of God in the Bible, resembles this description?
 
-------------------------------------------

DESIRED ATTRIBUTES FOR THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR

The next Executive Director should possess a combination of personal and spiritual character and professional experience that will enable him/her to lead the denomination to its next chapter of influence in the Kingdom of God. A deep commitment to Christ as Lord, personal character and integrity, proven and effective leadership skills, passion and enthusiasm, and a strong work ethic will be necessary to guide the Churches of God, General Conference. Beyond this, other specific attributes will be important. The next Executive Director will be:
• A person called by God to this position with a deep commitment to Christ and unquestioned personal integrity;
• A forward-thinking visionary who is strategic in thinking, planning and action;
• A strong communicator, gifted listener and inspiring influence;
• A person who is committed to local and global multiplication of disciples and faith communities;
• A person with proven leadership skills who is able to inspire trust, build consensus and lead appropriate teams;
• A person who holds the core values of the denomination deeply and intuitively;
• A person who can articulate to current and emerging generations that the Kingdom of God matters;
• A visible leader who is able to move comfortably among congregations of various size and cultures of various diversity.

Monday, September 15, 2014

eNews Shocker: ED ROSENBERRY RESIGNS

In a surprise move, Ed Rosenberry resigned as CGGC Executive Director effective June 30, 2105 as a part of his report to the most recent meeting of the CGGC Administrative Council.  Ed announced his resignation to the denomination in the September 12 article of the CGGC eNews, the weekly email update on his comings and goings.

In announcing the resignation, Ed said, "...there are challenges, but good things are happening too."  If the position has not been filled by the effective date of his resignation, Ed has offered to continue at the board’s pleasure as needed.

In explaining the decision, Ed noted: "The priorities God laid on my heart back in 2007 are being met...It’s time for next-generation leadership to take the helm" and, "Linda and I are convinced the Lord is leading us into a new phase of ministry...We believe the Lord would have us be engaged in church planting in Pennsylvania."

Response to the resignation by the Ad Council was businesslike.  This announcement of a search for Ed's successor appeared in the same edition of the eNews that carried the resignation:
The Churches of God, General Conference, based in Findlay, Ohio, is now receiving applications for the position of Executive Director of the denomination. Bill Reist, CGGC president, is serving as the chairperson of the transition team along with eight others from across the Church.
An application, position description and desired attributes of the Executive Director will be available on the Churches of God website after October 1, 2014 or by contacting wreist@collegefirst.org or revrockey@gmail.com. Applications received by December 15, 2014 will be given priority, with a decision to be made, Lord willing, by March 31, 2015.
For more information regarding values, beliefs and history of the CGGC you may visit http://www.cggc.org/about/ online. Please direct all inquiries pertaining to the Executive Director position to the e-mail addresses above and not to the CGGC offices.
The last paragraph of the announcement seems to suggest an openness to the hiring of someone from outside the CGGC.

-------------------------------

A few editorial comments:

1.  The CGGC is now at a crucial moment in determining its future for the Kingdom.  How it moves forward in regard to the opening in the position of CGGC ED may, in fact, determine if it has any future for God's Kingdom at all.

2.  I believe that the make up of the 'transition team' is crucial.  There truly is a Shepherd Mafia in the CGGC.  In recent generations, that small group  has chosen its next leader.  The two people we know are a part of the transition team are both Shepherd Mafia "flockists."  In my opinion, they are both men of integrity who are good-hearted.  They are, however, insiders who have prospered from the leadership culture which has led the CGGC's numerical and spiritual decline for generations.  Bill is, perhaps, the leading intellectual among insiders.  Jeff is a highly respected progressive.  Interestingly, neither are from the denomination's largest region, the ERC.

If the transition team is to act according to the leading of the Holy Spirit, it seems extremely likely to me that at least four members of the transition team will have to come from outside of the good-old-boy network that has been hiring CGGC leaders.  For this to happen, the insiders will have to begin by engaging in a significant act of repentance.

We should all pray that such repentance will take place.

3.  I already know exactly who I think should succeed Ed.  I have been thinking about how Ed should be succeeded for a long time.  I will announce who I think should be the next ED on a future thread on this blog, if God is willing.

Two hints:  I don't think it should be me and, if you are reading this and hoping for my support--or, more likely, hoping not to receive my support--it's not you, either.

4.  The CGGC needs to take this opportunity to, as the Old Testament prophets preached, turn from our wicked ways and live.  Through his resignation, Ed has made repentance and conversion a real possibility for the CGGC.  I pray that the CGGC body, from its highest mountain peaks to its most humble hollers, will seize upon this opportunity.